M4C Logo AHRC Logo

Charles Comerford

Theology, Divinity and Religion, University of Birmingham

Thesis title:

Is Wisdom Dead? Reconceptualising Wisdom in Light of the Maskil Figure at Qumran

New Title: “Rethinking Naming in Dead Sea Scrolls Research: A Case Study on “4QInstruction”

Names have a way of shaping our understanding of a text before we have even begun to read it. As Molly Zahn comments, “once an object or phenomenon is given a particular name or placed in a particular category, we approach that object or phenomenon with specific expectations in mind regarding what sort of thing it is” (2011, 93). For the manuscripts 1Q26, 4Q415–4Q418, 4Q418(a+c), and 4Q423―which were identified as different manuscript copies of the same text―English-speaking scholars often refer to this composition with names recommended by the editors in Discoveries in the Judean Desert volume 34 (DJD 34). Thus, scholars refer to these manuscripts collective as “4QInstruction” or they use its Hebrew name Musar le-Mevin, which translates to “Instruction for the Understanding One.” These names were proposed by the editors on the understanding that the text is predominately characterised by a series of admonitions directed by a speaker (who is presumed to be a teacher of sorts) to students who are most commonly referred to in the document as “mevin” in the singular. Because of this, the editors believed the composition corresponded best with the category of Wisdom literature (a generic category used for certain books in the Hebrew Bible and other ANE texts). The objective of this thesis is to re-examine this characterisation and suggest an alternative name that is based on an understanding of its purported literary genre.

Research Area

  • Theology, Divinity and Religion

Publications

  • "The Power of the Wisdom Label in Dead Sea Scrolls Research and the Curious Case of 4Q419 (4QInstruction-Like Composition A)." Dead Sea Discoveries, 2023.
  • "Categories and Boundaries Special Issue Introduction." Advances in Ancient Biblical and Near Eastern Research, 2023 (co-authored with Joseph Scales).
  • "Before Wisdom Literature: Examining Early Wisdom Studies in Dead Sea Scrolls Research," in The Scrolls and their Scholars: Past, Present, and Future (eds. M. Press and M. Monger; Leiden, Brill, forthcoming).
  • Review of Sacred Texts and Disparate Interpretations: Qumran Manuscripts Seventy Years Later: Proceedings of the International Conference Held at the John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, 24–26 October 2017. Edited by Henrik Drawnel (STDJ 113; Leiden: Brill, 2020). In Journal of Theological Studies, 2022.
  • Review of The Cave 3 Copper Scroll: A Symbolic Journey. By Jesper Høgenhaven (STDJ 132; Leiden: Brill, 2020) In Journal of Theological Studies, 2022.

Conferences

Organising:

  • Categories and Boundaries in Second Temple Jewish Literature, M4C CDF – University of Birmingham (March 2021)
  • The Dead Sea Scrolls as a Scholarly Phenomenon, University of Agder (December 2022)

Speaking:

  • Reframing Wisdom Literature, Kings College London (May 2019): "What Do We Talk About When We Talk About Wisdom? Terminology, Definition, and Genre"
  • EABS Graduate Symposium, Virtual Conference (April 2021): "Assessing the Value and Criteria of the 'Wisdom' Label for 4QInstruction"
  • Society of Biblical Literature, San Antonio (November 2021): "Before 'Wisdom Literature': Examining Insights from Early Research on Wisdom in the Dead Sea Scrolls"
  • EABS Annual Conference, Toulouse (July 2022): "The Power of the Sapiential Label in Qumran Scholarship and the Curious Case of 4Q419 (Instruction-Like Composition A)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls as a Scholarly Phenomenon, University of Agder (December 2022): "Workshop: Categories and Labels in Dead Sea Scrolls Research"
  • EABS Annual Conference, Sicily (July 2023): "What's in a Name? The Many Names of '4QInstruction'"
  • Society of Biblical Literature, San Antonio (November 2023): "4QInstruction: The Making of a Wisdom Text"
 

Public Engagement & Impact

  • Brilliant Club, Placement Tutor (2020-present)
  • UoB, Teaching Assistant (2021-present)

Memberships

  • Society of Biblical Literature (SBL)
  • Society of Old Testament Literature (SOTS)
  • European Association of Biblical Studies (EABS)