M4C Logo AHRC Logo

Matthew Madeley

Music, University of Birmingham

Thesis title:

Music and Esotericism in Britain: 1900-1950

Esotericism, referring to the religious or spiritual beliefs peripheral to a society’s dominant religious culture, has long been an important category in studies of early twentieth-century British and Irish literature and art. Scholars have argued that, far from being mere aesthetic window-dressing, esoteric ideas comprise the thematic content and belief-system of much modernist writing, and consequently recent interdisciplinary work has comprehensively explored Anglophone modernism’s fascination with spirituality, mysticism and occultism (Dutta, 2022; Materer, 1996; Monteith, 2007; Soud, 2016; Surrette, 1993). This thesis seeks to demonstrate that the same is true for British music of this period. A wealth of understudied musicians – Granville Bantock, Arnold Bax, Rutland Boughton, York Bowen, Clara Butt, Erik Chisholm, Rebecca Clarke, Bernard Van Dieren, John Foulds, Eugene Goossens, Cecil Gray, Joseph Holbrooke, Gustav Holst, John Ireland, Constant Lambert, Mary Lucas, Maud MacCarthy, Margaret Morris, Helen Perkin, Edmund Rubbra, Cyril Scott, Kaikhosru Sorabji, Evelyn Suart and Peter Warlock – were deeply interested in anthroposophy, astrology, Celtic mythology, eastern mysticism, hermeticism, nature mysticism, numerology, occultism, paganism, spirituality, tarot card readings, the teaching of Gurdjieff and Ouspensky, and theosophy. 

This study sets out to uncover the esoteric networks which existed amongst these musicians, building a holistic picture of this cultural phenomenon and its influence. By examining the key locations at which esotericism and modernism came into contact – The Cave of the Golden Calf, The Boathouse Studio of Mary Lucas, The Offices of the Theosophical Society in London, and The Sackbut music journal’s editorial team and contributors – through the analysis of primary and archival materials, I seek to reveal the cultural context of these esoteric networks and the influence esotericism had on musical modernism in Britain. 

Research Area

  • Music

Conferences

  • A Spectre of Death: An Analysis Concerning the Position of the Third Movement of Felix Mendelssohn's String Quartet No.6 in F minor, Opus 80, within his "Late Style" - Society for Music Analysis Theory and Analysis Graduate Students Conference - University of Oxford, 17-18 April 2024. 
  • The Mystical Father of Modern British Music: Analysing Cyril Scott's Second Piano Sonata in light of his Theosophical beliefs - Society for Music Analysis Theory and Analysis Graduate Students Conference - Royal Holloway, University of London, 30 April - 1 May 2025.
  • Music To-Day: John Foulds and the Entanglement of Musical Modernism and the Occult - Modernism and Its Art Worlds - Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini & Italian Institute for Applied Musicology, 6-8 June 2025.
  • Innovation through Restriction: Susan Spain-Dunk, Alice Verne-Bredt and the condensing of large-scale form in the Phantasy Genre - The Expansive Canvas - Trinity College Dublin & The Royal Irish Academy of Music, 26-28 August 2025. 
  • Mystical Meanings and Technical Leanings: Cyril Scott's Music: Its Secret Influence Throughout the Ages (1933) and John Foulds' Music To-Day: Its Heritage from the Past, and Legacy to the Future (1934) and the Relationship Between Composition and Esotericism - Royal Musical Association Graduate Conference - Royal Birmingham Conservatoire, 6-8 January 2026. 
  • Music from the Celtic Fringe: Celtic Identity and Internal Colonialism in Early Twentieth Century English, Welsh and Irish Music - Rediscovering Celtic Heritage - Trinity College Dublin, 26-27 February 2026. 
  • From Muddle to Masterpiece: Beethoven's Late String Quartets at 200 - Society for Music Analysis Theory and Analysis Graduate Students Conference - University of Cambridge, 30-31 March 2026. 
  • A Synthesis of East and West? John Foulds, Maud MacCarthy, Theosophy and the combination of European and Indian Music - Global Music History and Northern Europe in the 18th and 19th Centuries - University of Copenhagen, 15-16 May 2026. 
  • The Troglodytes of Heddon Street: Music at the Cave of the Golden Calf - North American British Music Studies Association Tenth Biennial Conference - Colorado College, 9-12 July 2026. 
  • Twentieth Century British Musical Responses to the Poetry of John Keats - The British Assoication for Romantic Studies International Conference - University of Birmingham, 29-31 July 2026. 
  • Music & Movement: The Influence of Margaret Morris (1891-1980) on British Music and Dance - The Royal Musical Association, Society for Musicology in Ireland and The European Association for Dance History Joint Annual Conference - Queen's University Belfast, 29 August - 1 September 2026
  • Phantasy Trio: Ethel Barns, Susan Spain-Dunk, Alice Verne-Bredt and the Cobbett Prize - Women and Musical Histories 1789–1914 Conference - Royal Academy of Music, 2-4 September 2026. 

Public Engagement & Impact

Theosophical Spirituality and the Music of John Foulds and Cyril Scott - Public Lecture at the English Music Festival, 23-26 May 2025.

Other Research Interests

  • History and practice of esotericism broadly conceived
  • Interdisciplinary studies in British music, literature and painting
  • Classical music of the Celtic Nations
  • Music criticism and journalism in 20th century Britain
  • Sketch Studies 
  • Analysis of British Music (1880-1960)
  • Music and Philosophy 

Memberships

  • Society for Music Analysis (2025-) 
  • European Society for the Study of Western Esotericism (2025-)
  • Royal Musical Association (2026-) 

Qualifications

  • MMus Musicology: University of Edinburgh (2023-2024) 
  • BA (Hons) in Music and Philosophy: University of Durham (2020-2023)